Budget Alternatives to Expensive Commander Cards: Save Hundreds Without Losing Power
2025-10-05 | 10 min read
Budget Alternatives to Expensive Commander Cards: Save Hundreds Without Losing Power
Commander staples like Rhystic Study ($45), Mana Crypt ($180), and Cyclonic Rift ($30) are incredible cards. They're also expensive.
Good news: You don't need them. This guide shows you budget alternatives that achieve similar effects for a fraction of the cost. We're talking 90% of the power for 10% of the price.
All prices from our nightly TCGplayer cache as of October 2025.
The Budget Philosophy
What Makes a Good Budget Alternative?
- Similar function - Does the same job (even if slightly worse)
- Significant savings - Costs 50-90% less
- Still playable - Not a trap card
- Available - Easy to find and buy
What's "Budget"?
For this guide:
- Expensive = $15+
- Budget = Under $5
- Ultra-budget = Under $1
Goal: Build 95% as strong for 20% of the cost.
Blue: Card Draw Engines
Expensive: Rhystic Study (~$45)
Draws 1-3 cards per turn cycle by taxing opponents. Incredibly consistent.
Budget Alternative 1: Mystic Remora (~$8)
Why it works:
- Same tax mechanic as Rhystic Study
- Often draws MORE cards early game
- Cumulative upkeep = pay {1} or sacrifice
- Can let it die after 3-4 turns of value
Comparison:
- Rhystic Study: Permanent, consistent
- Mystic Remora: Temporary, explosive
Verdict: 90% as good for 80% less. Great deal!
Budget Alternative 2: Consecrated Sphinx (~$30... wait)
Actually budget: Windfall (~$0.50)
Why it works:
- Everyone draws 7 cards
- Refills your hand instantly
- Political tool (make friends!)
- One-time effect but huge value
Comparison:
- Rhystic Study: Slow, consistent
- Windfall: Fast, explosive
Verdict: Different but equally powerful. $0.50 for a hand refill!
Budget Alternative 3: Coastal Piracy (~$0.75)
Why it works:
- Draw when your creatures deal combat damage
- Works in creature-heavy decks
- Multiple triggers per turn
- Enchantment = hard to remove
Comparison:
- Rhystic Study: Universal
- Coastal Piracy: Creature decks only
Verdict: 80% as good in the right deck for 98% less!
Budget Alternative 4: Bident of Thassa (~$0.50)
Why it works:
- Same as Coastal Piracy
- ALSO forces opponents to attack (political!)
- Artifact = survives enchantment hate
- Dirt cheap
Verdict: Same as Coastal Piracy with upside. $0.50 is a steal!
Use our assistant to find more blue draw → "Blue card draw engines under $5"
Colorless: Fast Mana
Expensive: Mana Crypt (~$180)
Why it's good: Turn 0: Mana Crypt → you're ahead 2 mana forever.
Budget Alternative 1: Sol Ring (~$1.50)
Why it's almost as good:
- Costs {1} instead of {0}
- Still produces {C}{C}
- No life loss downside
- In every Commander deck
Comparison:
- Mana Crypt: Turn 0 play, -3 life per turn sometimes
- Sol Ring: Turn 1 play, no downside
Verdict: 95% as good for 99% less. Buy this first!
Budget Alternative 2: Mana Vault (~$25)
Why it's good:
- Costs {1} like Sol Ring
- Produces {C}{C}{C} (more than Crypt!)
- Downside: 1 damage per turn + doesn't untap
- Can untap for {4}
Comparison:
- Mana Crypt: Free, always active
- Mana Vault: Costs {1}, temporary burst
Verdict: 70% as good for 85% less. Best for combo decks.
Budget Alternative 3: Mind Stone (~$0.50)
Why it's practical:
- Costs {2}, produces {C}
- Can sacrifice to draw a card (late-game value!)
- No downside
- Ultra-cheap
Comparison:
- Mana Crypt: Explosive, early game
- Mind Stone: Consistent, flexible
Verdict: 40% as good but only $0.50. Run both!
Budget Alternative 4: Arcane Signet (~$0.50)
Why it's essential:
- Costs {2}, produces any color in your commander's identity
- Perfect mana fixing
- Goes in every deck
- Heavily reprinted = cheap
Verdict: Different role (fixing vs. ramp) but equally important. $0.50!
Blue: Board Wipes
Expensive: Cyclonic Rift (~$30)
Why it's good: {6}{U} = bounce all non-land permanents you don't control. Instant speed. One-sided. Wins games.
Budget Alternative 1: Evacuation (~$1.50)
Why it works:
- {3}{U}{U} = bounce all creatures
- Instant speed
- Symmetrical (you bounce yours too)
- 95% cheaper!
Comparison:
- Cyclonic Rift: One-sided, hits all nonlands
- Evacuation: Symmetrical, creatures only
Verdict: 75% as good for 95% less. Great in creature-light decks!
Budget Alternative 2: Devastation Tide (~$0.50)
Why it works:
- {3}{U}{U} = bounce all nonland permanents
- Miracle {1}{U} (can cast for 2 mana if drawn first!)
- Symmetrical
- Ultra-cheap
Comparison:
- Cyclonic Rift: One-sided, instant
- Devastation Tide: Symmetrical, sometimes 2 mana!
Verdict: 70% as good for 98% less. Miracle makes it worth it!
Budget Alternative 3: Wash Out (~$0.75)
Why it's clever:
- {3}{U} = bounce all permanents of chosen color
- Can target opponents' main color
- Leaves your stuff if you're different colors
- Political tool
Comparison:
- Cyclonic Rift: Universal
- Wash Out: Color-specific
Verdict: Situational but powerful. $0.75 for targeted removal!
White: Board Wipes
Expensive: Austere Command (~$5)
Actually not expensive! But let's find cheaper:
Budget Alternative: Wrath of God (~$8)
Wait, that's more expensive...
Actual Budget: Day of Judgment (~$1.50)
Why it's great:
- {2}{W}{W} = destroy all creatures
- Clean, simple, effective
- Reprinted many times
- Does the same job as expensive wraths
Verdict: Exactly as good as $8 Wrath of God. Save money!
Ultra-Budget: Dusk // Dawn (~$0.50)
Why it's clever:
- {2}{W}{W} = destroy all creatures with power 3+
- Keeps your small creatures!
- Other side returns small creatures from graveyard
- Often one-sided
Verdict: Better in token/weenie decks. $0.50!
Green: Ramp Spells
Expensive: Three Visits (~$8)
Why it's good: {1}{G} = put a Forest onto the battlefield (untapped).
Budget Alternative 1: Nature's Lore (~$2.50)
Why it's identical:
- {1}{G} = put a Forest onto the battlefield
- Works with dual lands with Forest type (Breeding Pool, etc.)
- Same card, different name
- Slightly cheaper
Verdict: Literally the same card. Save $5!
Budget Alternative 2: Rampant Growth (~$0.25)
Why it's good enough:
- {1}{G} = put a basic land onto the battlefield
- Enters tapped (only downside vs. Nature's Lore)
- Ultra-cheap
- Does the job
Comparison:
- Nature's Lore: Untapped, any Forest
- Rampant Growth: Tapped, basic only
Verdict: 90% as good for 90% less. Buy 4 copies for the price of one Three Visits!
Budget Alternative 3: Cultivate / Kodama's Reach (~$0.50 each)
Why they're amazing:
- {2}{G} = get 2 lands (1 to battlefield, 1 to hand)
- Guarantees next land drop
- Fixes colors in multicolor decks
- Heavily reprinted = cheap
Verdict: Different effect (3 mana vs 2 mana) but better value. $0.50!
Red: Card Draw
Expensive: Jeska's Will (~$18)
Why it's good: {2}{R} = add mana equal to opponents' cards OR exile 3 and play them. Ritual + draw in one.
Budget Alternative 1: Thrill of Possibility (~$0.10)
Search for Thrill of Possibility →
Why it works:
- {1}{R} = discard 1, draw 2
- Instant speed
- Rummaging (card selection)
- Literally 10 cents!
Comparison:
- Jeska's Will: Explosive, expensive
- Thrill of Possibility: Consistent, cheap
Verdict: Different but effective. $0.10!
Budget Alternative 2: Faithless Looting (~$0.25)
Search for Faithless Looting →
Why it's efficient:
- {R} = draw 2, discard 2
- Flashback (cast again from graveyard)
- Card selection
- Graveyard synergies
Verdict: One of red's best draw spells. $0.25!
Budget Alternative 3: Wheel of Fortune (~$350)
Nope, that's expensive. Try...
Actual Budget: Windfall (~$0.50)
Why it's powerful:
- {2}{U} = everyone discards hand, draws 7
- Refills your hand completely
- Political tool
- Blue, but works in Izzet/Grixis
Verdict: Different role but incredibly powerful. $0.50!
Black: Tutors
Expensive: Demonic Tutor (~$45)
Why it's good: {1}{B} = search library for any card. Instant speed in your mind. Finds answers.
Budget Alternative 1: Diabolic Tutor (~$0.50)
Why it's good enough:
- {2}{B}{B} = search library for any card
- Same effect, costs 2 more mana
- Still finds exactly what you need
- 99% cheaper!
Comparison:
- Demonic Tutor: 2 mana, premium
- Diabolic Tutor: 4 mana, budget
Verdict: 80% as good for 99% less. Easy choice!
Budget Alternative 2: Merchant of Asphodel (~$0.25)
Wait, wrong card...
Actual Budget: Beseech the Queen (~$1.50)
Search for Beseech the Queen →
Why it's clever:
- {2/B}{2/B}{2/B} = search for card with CMC ≤ lands you control
- Turn 6+ finds anything
- Can cast early for 3 mana to find 3-drops
- Flexible
Verdict: Restriction makes it weaker but still strong. $1.50!
Budget Alternative 3: Diabolic Intent (~$3)
Why it's powerful:
- {1}{B} = sacrifice creature, search for any card
- Same cost as Demonic Tutor!
- Works in aristocrats/tokens
- Requires setup
Verdict: 90% as good in sacrifice decks for 93% less!
Complete Budget Deck Formula
Replace every expensive card:
$500 Deck:
- Mana Crypt ($180)
- Rhystic Study ($45)
- Cyclonic Rift ($30)
- Demonic Tutor ($45)
- Fetch lands x3 ($150)
- Other staples ($50)
Total: $500
$50 Budget Deck:
- Sol Ring ($1.50)
- Mystic Remora ($8)
- Evacuation ($1.50)
- Diabolic Tutor ($0.50)
- Evolving Wilds x3 ($0.75)
- Other staples ($37.75)
Total: $50
Power level drop: ~10%
Cost savings: 90%
Worth it!
How to Find Budget Alternatives
Method 1: Use Our Assistant
Examples:
- "Budget alternatives to Rhystic Study"
- "Cheap blue board wipes"
- "Red card draw under $1"
The assistant searches by function, not just name!
Method 2: Search by Function
Examples:
- "Draw cards" in blue
- "Board wipe" in white
- "Ramp" in green
- Sort by price: Low to High
Method 3: EDHREC Budget Filters
Visit EDHREC, use budget filters, find alternatives.
Method 4: Ask Your Playgroup
Someone probably has budget versions they're happy with!
When to Splurge vs Save
Always Buy Budget Versions:
- Board wipes - Day of Judgment = Wrath of God functionally
- Ramp spells - Cultivate = Explosive Vegetation
- Basic removal - Swords to Plowshares is already cheap!
Consider Splurging On:
- Unique effects - No budget replacement for Doubling Season
- Commanders - If your deck requires specific commander
- Key combo pieces - If deck doesn't work without it
Never Splurge On:
- Mana Crypt - Sol Ring does 95% of the work
- Original duals - Shock lands are fine
- Reserved List cards - Prices only go up, buy proxies or alternatives
Price Tracking Tips
Use our tools to save money:
Track Prices
Prices fluctuate! Buy during reprint announcements (prices drop).
Scan Before Buying
Use our scanner at card shows →
Find deals in bulk bins by scanning quickly!
Compare Printings
View all printings on card pages →
Commander 2015 Sol Ring: $1.50
Alpha Sol Ring: $5,000
Same card. Buy the cheap one!
Conclusion: Build Smarter, Not Richer
You don't need to spend $500 to build a powerful Commander deck. With smart substitutions, you can build 90-95% as strong for 10-20% of the cost.
Key Takeaways:
- Function over price - Focus on what the card does
- Budget alternatives exist - Someone always made a cheaper version
- Use our tools - Assistant, search, scanner help find deals
- Power ≠ price - A $0.50 card can win games
Ready to build budget?
- Find budget alternatives → "Budget cards that do X"
- Browse cheap staples →
- Build your deck →
- Scan cards at shows →
Happy budget brewing! Your wallet will thank you. 🎴💰
Disclosure: This site uses affiliate links. When you buy cards through our TCGplayer links, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Card data courtesy of Scryfall. Prices from TCGplayer via tcgcsv.com.